Sunday 30 March 2014

Round 2 - Essendon v Hawthorn

Arise, Sir Cyril


Etihad Stadium, Friday 28 March 2014

Cue hysteria
Prime Minister Tony Abbott reintroduced the imperial honours system this week and although his favourite little love buddy, General Peter Cosgrove, has been awarded the first gong (Tony has a thing for uniforms), I nominate that the next two should be awarded to Shaun Burgoyne and Cyril Rioli for their match winning performances against Essendon on Friday night. Not that a knighthood comes close to what they deserve, but it’s a start.

Of course I imagine that both players would refuse such an irrelevant, outdated honour, particularly in light of the other piece of retrograde legislation the Attorney General, Senator George Brandis, is trying to introduce – the watering down of section 18C of the vilification laws to virtually sanction race hate speech, but sometimes it’s just nice to asked.

Josh Gibson played a great game too, his 150th in fact, but he already has a Peter Crimmins medal and a premiership medal, and both carry far greater prestige than a knighthood from Tony Abbott.

I was watching the match at home with my family. Angela and our youngest son Declan had gone to bed, but knowing the scores were close both had got back up because they knew Oscar and I would be making a racket in the dying minutes – of either the exulted or excruciating variety – and that sleep would be impossible.

Their instinct was right. With just over a minute to go, Isaac Smith soccered the ball forward twice to clear packs, and when Luke Breust got it over to Bradley Hill, I rose from my seat shouting “Come on come on”, then as Hill measured a handball to Rioli, Oscar also rose, and by the time Cyril slammed home the winning goal we were all up and screaming the name Cyyrrrilll! – waking up anyone within a 5km radius. And given we live in Essendon, that made it even more satisfying.

Conscious Uncoupling


The match was billed as a blockbuster, so again you might question why it wasn’t played at the MCG. This is the third year in succession that Hawthorn has played Essendon at Etihad Stadium, and yet the AFL is voicing concerns about crowd numbers. Go figure.

Well I didn’t go to this match precisely because it was at Etihad Stadium. Getting tickets to Essendon home games is virtually impossible, plus if you do happen to get in, you then have to listen to Essendon’s feral fans all night (as opposed to the cultured sophisticates that barrack for Hawthorn).   Again, this match was billed as ’sold out’ despite the numerous empty seats visible on the television coverage. It may sound old fashioned, but my advice to the good people at the AFL and Etihad is to put the tickets on sale, and they might actually get sold.

The build-up to the match was dominated by all-to-predictable references to past clashes from the 80s and onwards – the 85 Grand Final brawl, Brereton-Duckworth, the line in the sand brawl, Lloyd-Sewell etc – I paraphrase because it’s exactly the same every year. In the same way that obituaries of noteworthy people are pre-recorded and ready to go at the drop of the hat, or a kick of the bucket, there are ready made introductions to Hawthorn-Essendon games that feature exactly the same footage every year. Commentators relay this history as if we’ve never heard it before. Just as the news on Boxing Day evening is always a variation on the same theme – the MCG Test match, the Sydney to Hobart yacht race, so too previews of Hawthorn-Essendon games.

This year, however, there was an added element – the ‘no Buddy’ factor. Buddy Franklin kicked 8 goals last time Hawthorn played Essendon. This was in addition to two previous bags of 9 against them, plus the two famous running goals at the MCG in 2010.  So this year commentators were suggesting that with no Buddy, this was a new landscape for a Hawthorn-Essendon game, with the underlying suggestion that in the absence of Hawthorn’s usual match-winner in this fixture, Essendon might have a chance.

During the week actress Gwyneth Paltrow made news when she announced that she was separating from husband, Chris Martin, lead singer of soft-rock outfit, Coldplay. The split wasn’t news so much as the phrase she used to describe it – “conscious uncoupling” – instead of “divorce”, “separation” or “musical differences” and as opposed to “unconscious coupling” such as might occur after a work Christmas party.

As has been well documented, Buddy Franklin left Hawthorn for Sydney at the end of 2013, in what might also be called a “conscious uncoupling.”  Most Hawks fans have gotten over it, even his most ardent admirers like me, so the constant reiterating of his departure and what effect it might have has just become tiresome, and we’re only two games into the season. You can only imagine how tedious this will become in the build-up to the Hawthorn-Sydney game in Round 8.




Half truth


Truth be told, I felt a certain foreboding about this game, a presentiment that was only heightened when news came through that Sam Mitchell was ruled out injured. This was far worse than the fact that Franklin wasn’t playing, if only because Mitchell at least is a Hawthorn player. Already missing key tall defenders Brian Lake and Ben Stratton, as well as midfielder Brad Sewell, this was unwelcome news indeed. It could only get worse if Luke Hodge were to become injured…

On the other hand, Cyril Rioli was back for his first game of the season, and where there’s Cyril, there’s hope.

Essendon started the game well, maintaining possession and looking dangerous. But half-way through the quarter Hawthorn had the only three goals of the match, through Luke Breust, Bradley Hill and Jarryd Roughead, whose shot was an audacious roost over his head while facing away from goal. All was looking well – even if it was in the wrong direction.

Even when Essendon’s peppering of the goals finally yielded a major, Hawthorn responded with a goal to Gunston, and despite the play being fairly even, Hawthorn held a handsome 14 point lead.

The second quarter followed a similar pattern; the play was more or less even but Hawthorn was more precise across the field and more accurate in front of goal. We kicked five goals to two, including a couple of beauties from the long, accurate left boot of Matthew Suckling.

By half-time the lead was 32 points and I was composing cocky text messages to send to Bombers fans.

Our outsized and relatively inexperienced defenders Taylor Duryea and Kyle Cheney were competing strongly against their taller opponents, as was debutant Angus Litherland, and with Gibson, Hodge and Birchall playing their usual strong games, there didn’t appear to be too much to worry about.

Cloak app


There’s a new anti-social app growing in popularity called ‘Cloak’ that reads data from the devices of people in your contacts list and displays it so that you can avoid running into them. Perfect for evading former lovers, your boss, or indeed anyone you know should you happen to be out with someone other than your partner.

Perfect also for avoiding your team mates, as it seemed that every Hawthorn player had downloaded the app at half-time, despite the ruling about no mobile phones in the rooms. I don’t know if it was the Cloak app or something else, but in the third quarter handballs missed targets, kicks went to no one in particular, or worse, to Essendon players and our defenders were nowhere near their Essendon opponents. Soon after Hodge was penalised for deliberate out of bounds, from which Essendon goaled, he limped off injured and was subbed out of the game.

Special comments
It seemed like the umpires too had activated some version of the Cloak app for they couldn’t see Hawthorn players at all but found regular occasion to award Essendon free kicks in front of goal. The only person keener to find a free kick for Essendon was Dennis Cometti, who was barracking away for the Bombers in the commentary box – what was that all about? In Federal Parliament during the week the Opposition sought a no confidence vote on the speaker, Bronwyn Bishop, on the grounds of manifest bias. I felt like moving the same motion on Dennis Cometti.

A six goal to zero third quarter and all of a sudden we were behind at the final break. We simply weren’t able to get hold of the ball. My pre-match premonition seemed to be playing out and I was glad I was at home and not cowering somewhere on Level 3 at Etihad.

Watching from Japan, my friend Chan-Tha emailed a simple “WTF!”

The way it was going I was going to need to download the Cloak app so I could elude Essendon fans for a few weeks.

The Burgoyne is better


When Jackson Merrett kicked the opening goal of the final quarter for Essendon, the outlook grew even gloomier. Of our forward line, Roughead and Gunston were being well held, Tim O’Brien was unsighted and while Breust and Rioli were trying hard, we just weren’t creating opportunities for them.

Hawthorn was suffering through an uncharacteristic goal drought that had begun in the second quarter and didn’t look like breaking any time soon, until a classic piece of play in the 15th minute by the Poo, Paul Puopolo, got the first trickle flowing.

In a classic goal for goal denouement, Patrick Ambrose responded for Essendon, followed by Simpkin for Hawthorn, after some brilliant work by Burgoyne – gathering the ball in the pocket, he turned and was running along the goal line by the behind post, but instead of attempting an unlikely snap, he squared the ball to Simpkin who was 20 metres out directly in front.

The next goal was kicked by Paul Chapman to put Essendon 10 points ahead with only three minutes to go. Last year when there was talk that Chapman would leave Geelong, I advocated that Hawthorn should recruit him, not necessarily for him to play, just to prevent him from playing against us! Feeling vindicated didn’t make me feel any better after he had kicked what appeared to be the sealer.

Hawthorn’s response came immediately – Burgoyne sharked the tap and kicked long where Breust trapped it and snapped a goal on his left. It took just 10 seconds from Chapman’s goal and we were back within a goal. Then with just over a minute to go Essendon’s David Myers (wearing no. 23 it should be noted) kicked on the full. From the free kick Hawthorn moved the ball quickly and Smith, Breust and Hill combined to get it to Cyril for the match winner.

Burgoyne won the ball again from the next bounce and kicked long to Rioli who measured a pass to Hill. Hill missed, but in Essendon’s scramble to get the ball forward, Roughead was alone at half back to take the mark and end the match.

There really is no better way to win a game of football than a goal with a minute or so to go. And kicking it into the Hawthorn fans end of the stadium provided a glorious backdrop of brown and gold mayhem for the celebratory group hug.


Final scores: Hawthorn 13. 12. 90  d  Essendon 12. 14. 86

Attendance: 44,163

Ladder position: 5th


What we learned: The magic number 23 was again pivotal to Hawthorn’s win. This time it was Essendon’s David Myers’ hurried kick out of a pack that gave Hawthorn possession in the crucial final minute.

According to the statistics, our own number 23, Tim O’Brien, had four touches, although I must have missed them. The only touch I saw him get was when he signed a souvenir football at the end for one of the kids ringing the boundary.  Still, Clarko and the selectors know what they’re doing and our number 23 is coming along nicely. Remember, Dermie was a redhead before he went blond, so the potential is there.


What we already knew: A little bit of Rough can sometimes be enough. Jarryd Roughead wasn’t a major influence on the match, yet anyone watching the highlights package might think that he dominated the game. At times you needed radar technology and satellite data to prove that he was even out there, but when they run the highlights reel, you’ll see his over the head goal in the first quarter, his big leap and one handed pluck in the second quarter and his match saving mark at the end of the match. So he kicked goal of the night, took the mark of the night and saved the game.


Kim Jong-heppell: It’s been reported that North Korean leader, Kim Jong-un, has decreed that all male university students must adopt the same haircut that he sports – a short back and sides with an 80s fop, or what resembles a small marsupial on top. This seems somewhat extreme, but the male university students don’t seem to mind. After all, it would be worse if Dyson Heppell became the supreme leader of North Korea.





What do you mean I need to grow up?: Is this immature – on Saturday morning I had occasion to drive past Windy Hill and as I did so, I opened the window and yelled out “Cyrriill!” There was nobody around but it still felt good.

Wednesday 26 March 2014

Round 1 - Hawthorn v Brisbane

Hawthorn - Forever in Fashion


Hawthorn v Brisbane Lions
Aurora Stadium - Saturday 22 March 2014




The 2014 AFL season dawned in a very literal sense for me. I was happily ensconced on a plane watching the sun rise from above the clouds as we straightened out on our way from Melbourne to Launceston. Not just literal; the sun’s bright, effulgent glow seemed an auspicious way to start the new season and Hawthorn’s defence of its 2013 premiership.

Round 1 of the 2014 season was spread over nine long days and we were just dragging ourselves into the eighth of those. The two weekends of the round bookended the Melbourne Fashion Festival, and if the couture of those aboard my Jetstar flight was any indication, then brown and gold are definitely ‘in’ this season. Two out of every three people on board were wearing either a Hawthorn jumper or jacket, in some cases both, or accessorising with scarves and badges.  Of course this is not a seasonal fad; in my mind Hawthorn is forever in fashion.

It wasn’t just Round 1 that was dragging on. It seemed that season 2013 was still going, and not just because Hawthorn fans continued to gloat over the premiership, but the newspapers I flicked through inflight were full of the Essendon supplements scandal. Tania Hird, in an interview on ABC’s 7.30, had re-aired her gripes about Andrew Demetriou and how he made her husband James a scapegoat (for what, exactly?).

Essendon Chairman Paul Little’s subsequent comment that James needs to control those around him is, you could argue, the cause of the problem in the first place. If Hird had more control over those mixing the cocktails and wielding needles, then perhaps the supplements program might not have gone as far as it did.

I saw this interview not so much as a re-opening of old battles, but an orchestrated event to stir the emotions of the Essendon faithful and create the ‘us against the world’ spirit that served them quite well for long stretches of 2013. And it seemed to work because they won quite handsomely against North Melbourne on the Friday night. Not that the Hirds saw it - they were winging their way to Paris where James was set to commence an all-expenses-paid study program while Tania and the kids enjoyed a holiday. If that’s their idea of persecution, then pin the blame on me.

At large in Launceston


My decision to go to Launceston for the opening game was hastily arranged in the week of the match, so accommodation in Launceston was as scarce as Brisbane fans. I ended up in a single room at the TRC Hotel, which is essentially an old pub transformed into a sports bar – which actually just means it’s a TAB. The room was rudimentary – single bed, table, chair, wardrobe, television, sink, toilet and shower stall – but pretty good value at $60 a night.

Brisbane Street mall is festively decorated with Hawthorn bunting and banners, and many of the shop windows feature brown and gold displays. It’s just after 9am and visiting footy fans wander aimlessly about and fill up the cafes. Birchalls (the shop, not the family of Hawthorn’s Grant) has a great display of my book, ‘High on Hawthorn’, so I introduce myself and sign some copies. Petrarchs, also in Brisbane Street mall, is a good book shop also carrying stock of the book, so I chat to the store owners about books and football.

The match isn’t until 4.40pm so some time in mid-afternoon I walk to the ground. I’m quite early but decide not to pop into a pub, thinking I’ll grab a beer at the ground and sit in the afternoon sun to drink it. Here I discover an unpleasant truth – the bars aren’t open! The match is only an hour away and for reasons which aren’t clear to me, I can’t get a drink. I can’t watch the flag unfurled without raising a drink in toast.

Happily the natural order is soon restored and the bars open. A queue forms immediately. The beer, however, is served in mid-strength cups.



Birchalls window
Cyril - there in spirit - or at least canvass
















Something off the back of a ute 


As far as flag ceremonies go, Hawthorn’s unfurling of the 2013 flag must rank as a masterpiece of understatement. In the Olympics Games opening ceremony, half a dozen former sporting champions take about an hour and a half to slowly march the full perimeter of the arena before handing it to a white-gloved general to hoist it slowly up the pole. In military ceremonies, canons are set off, or bugles blown as the flag is unfolded one inch at a time in a bizarre choreographic textile display, while regimented ranks of uniformed personnel stand at stiff salute. In 2011, Collingwood had a guard of honour, laser shows, fireworks, anthemic music, a parade of past champions, possibly even a priest, plus Simon Prestigiacomo looking down from the roof of the Great Southern Stand like Spiderman. I think it was directed by Baz Luhrmann. At Hawthorn, we had the players in their training tops and Brian Lake in the back of a ute.

The flag unfurling extravaganzas!


It’s a quaint tradition – unfurling the premiership flag at the first home match the following season. I’m sure premiership coaches who have spent all summer trying to get their players to forget the past and focus on the forthcoming season don’t appreciate this ceremony of looking back. Perhaps it would be better if it was done at the same time they present the cup, in the rooms after the Grand Final or at the best and fairest dinner. Or in any circumstance that involves it being wound tightly around Kylie’s shimmering body. Brian Lake could grab the pointy bit at the end (of the flag that is) and give it a good tug to send Kylie into a fast spin so that the flag unwinds until she’s deflagged. Like the dance of the seven veils, but with just one flag.

One time honoured ceremony we shouldn’t mess with is the team bursting through the banner to enter the arena. This is a tradition that adds colour and provides an inspirational message to players and fans alike, or at least an ad from the major sponsor. The banner, or run-through, serves as a formal welcome to the team. It’s a crepe paper membrane, the liminal barrier between society and the sporting arena. Like white line fever, but gold crepe fever. But it is more than that. You don’t have to be Freud to see that on a much deeper level the act of bursting through the banner is the re-enactment of the birth moment. The players move down the race, or birth canal, and then break through the banner in a manner reminiscent of parturition. It is a metaphorical rebirth for the team each week. So when Brisbane ran out with no banner, did it mean that they remained unborn – and therefore without a chance – or was it a caesarean? Or was it just that there weren’t enough Brisbane fans at the ground to hold up a banner?

Footy is back!


There are certain signs that football is back. The leaves are beginning to turn, the shops are full of Easter eggs and Sam Mitchell is getting flattened behind play – this time by Brisbane’s Tom Rockliff in the very first passage of play. This early in the season and the Hawks are a little rusty; our dinky kicks are being regularly picked off and the Lions score the first goal.

For several years it’s been a fair bet that our first goal will come from the boot of no. 23, and this was to be no exception. Not Franklin this time, but new boy Tim O’Brien playing his first game. T.O.B.  took a fine mark and slotted a set shot from 50 metres. When Big Ben McEvoy kicked our third goal for the quarter we were left feeling grateful that these new boys were on hand – where would we have been without them?

The second quarter was marked by a great running goal to Liam Shiels, followed by Burgoyne setting up first Rough and then Shiels again. When Gunston marked it looked like we were going to romp away, but The Gun, or Gunstall, as I’ve heard him called, missed. Then he missed another set shot. When Langford and Shiels also missed set shots, we’d gone from 7.3 to 7.6 and our chance to wrap up the match early dissipated.

One thing that became apparent in the second quarter was Clarko’s much vaunted new game plan. All summer there has been talk about how he would tweak the game plan to suit our new personnel and avoid the trap of 2009 where the other teams picked apart our ‘cluster’ with great success. We weren’t going to let that happen again. The new game plan is so simple it’s beautiful: if in doubt kick it high in McEvoy’s general vicinity, a strategy we employed very successfully all day simply because he kept marking it.

A 22 point half-time lead seemed comfortable enough, especially when Breeeuust slotted another one just after the break. But then Brisbane started to get on top. They were playing with energy and endeavour, particularly Daniel Rich. You can forget how good he is until you see him again.  After a fantastic goal to Breust from the 50 metres out on the boundary, the Lions added the next three to close the margin to just two points.  One of them after a Hodge tried a dinky kick with his right foot out wide that only travelled only as far as a Brisbane forward who was just standing around minding his own business when the ball suddenly appeared in front of him at marking height. He calmly took it and slotted the goal.

This was one of a few miskicks of Hodge’s. Watching from Melbourne, Chan-Tha and Pete posted that his new fluro orange boots were to blame. A few of the players were sporting them. They were so bright that perhaps the act of bringing his leg up to kick the ball momentarily blinded him and affected his kick.

We were starting to shift a little uneasily. I had been to Launceston only once previously, in 2009, and that was also to see us play Brisbane. That too was the year after winning the premiership and we lost on that occasion. Surely not again…

…which must have been more or less what Jarryd Roughead was thinking. He yawned, stretched and bustled his way into the action where he snagged a couple for the quarter. As did Breust and Sammy and we were back out to a good lead. In between all this, Jonathan Brown took a classic Brown mark running back with the flight of the ball. As heroic as the mark was, I was still grateful when he missed the kick.

The three quarter time lead was back out to 25 points, but as the final quarter got underway the Hawks started to break clear. Brisbane’s Trent West kicked the first of the quarter but then Gunston regained his aim and slotted a couple, Roughead added another and Breust got his fifth. Hawthorn’s next goal came from Matthew Suckling, playing his first game back since the 2013 pre-season. Suckling’s extraordinary kicking was back to the fore and both he and Taylor Duryea had played well rebounding off half back. Duryea had even competed strongly against the taller, stronger Jonathan Brown.

By this stage twilight was turning to evening and the clouds massing on the mountain overlooking Aurora were shot through with a purple tinge, courtesy of the sunset. Was it nature’s beauty or simply that the Hawks were maintaining a 45 or so point lead that suffused me with a Zen like calm as I sat and watched the final minutes of the match? Roughead added a fifth himself near the end and then Smith popped one through to complete an eight goal final quarter and help hawks fans find oneness.

It was good to see the boys back in action: Bradley Hill, Luke Breust, Liam Shiels, Grant Birchall and Ben McEvoy all played well, as did Sam Mitchell, Shaun Burgoyne, Jordan Lewis and Isaac Smith.   Debutant Derick Wanganeen had a bit of a run late and Langford flaunted his surname.  All in all a satisfying win by the Hawks, one befitting my bright dawn vision.

It was like Grand Final night in Launceston after the match, i.e. the streets were full of packs of drunk Hawthorn fans just wandering about. Perhaps there was a good reason why Aurora serves mid-strength and delays the opening of the bars.

Final scores: Hawthorn 21 13 139  d  Brisbane 13 13 91

Ladder position – 4th

Attendance: 12,430

What we learned: People watch ABC’s 7.30 in larger numbers than we might have suspected. That’s if the furore created by Tania Hird’s appearance on the show is any indication of viewing figures.  Who knew? I only watch it when Leigh Sales is hosting. Perhaps other low rating shows might consider having Tania on to boost their ratings. She could be a guest judge on The Voice or Masterchef. Then James wouldn’t have to work at all.

What we already knew: Age columnist Martin Flanagan is an old softy. In his regular column for the Saturday Age he never fails to highlight, using the prism of football, the plight of the poor, sick and downtrodden. There’s always some story about a bloke who loves a yarn or doesn’t mind a drink, who fought at Gallipoli and returned with just one leg, but still played in a forward pocket for Fitzroy; or war widow Mabel who has barracked for Footscray since 1925 and was in the original Hyde Street band to play at the Western oval, or Wazza who used to sell the Footy Record at Victoria Park and knew John Wren, but whose inner city cottage was forcibly claimed to allow the Eastern freeway to be built, after which he suffered a long illness, clinging to life only just long enough to see the Pies win the 1990 premiership…you know the sort of thing.

This week, however, Marty hints that he might be retiring. He doesn’t say it in so many words, but he’s managed to find a sob story to fit every team, even the Giants, and provide him with a heart warming tale no matter which team claims the flag. I fear that he’s gone too early – that’s a whole season’s worth of material and he’s blown it at Round 1.

What we didn’t know but should have suspected: The Essendon supplements scandal is all Eddie’s fault! At last the truth comes out. One of James Hird’s media advisers, Ian Hanke, in the midst of a Twitter outburst about Andrew Demetriou and the AFL’s handling of the investigation, suddenly suggested that club presidents such as McGuire should go. Now I’m no apologist for Eddie, but whatever faults he may have, I fail to see how he is implicated in this saga. To give Essendon their due - one of the first people they sacked was their unwitting president, Ian Robson, so they are at least walking their own talk. But it does seem that every few weeks Hird’s camp anoints a new public enemy number one. So far they’ve so far tried to blame Age journalist Caroline Wilson, AFL CEO Andrew Demetriou and now Collingwood president Eddie McGuire. Quite possibly James Hird is innocent and Tania is justified and correct, but whoever is responsible for whatever did happen at Essendon, it seems a tad far-fetched to level the blame at this trio.

What we therefore don’t understand: If James Hird and ‘those around him’ hate the AFL and everyone involved in running the game so much, why is he so adamant about returning? For the rest of us - if we don’t like our workplace, our boss, our clients or the industry we find ourselves working in, then the normal course of action is to consider an alternative career.

Really, everyone should stop moaning and give thanks that, for this week at least, Collingwood is on the bottom of the ladder.


Hawthorn Haiku

Orange fluro boots
The flag unfurled in a ute
Clouds on the mountain


Tuesday 18 March 2014

Footy's Back...is it?


There’s a weird vibe around town at the moment. People are carrying on saying that footy’s back, The Age and the Herald-Sun are both filling out with pages and pages of arcane footyesque speculation (which team has the most ‘recycled’ players on their list, why it’s time North must deliver, why we should have a night Grand Final, Essendon players suffering from low morale - that’s morale, not morals -  etc ), the television is back showing revelatory footage of footballers handballing to each other at training and coaches getting in and out of cars, and ASADA’s investigation into Essendon moves into its 13th month – the Nuremberg trials, by comparison, ran for just over 10 months, from 20 November 1945 to 1 October 1946. Of course at Nuremberg they were only looking into the crimes of the Third Reich, not the Hird Reich, but if the timeline of the investigation is any indication, ASADA must believe Essendon’s crimes to be even more heinous than the Nazis. I doubt even Dermie wouldn’t go that far.

But if footy’s back, I don’t see it. Sure there are matches for premiership points, sure Caroline Wilson is already banging on about sacking coaches, or at least the boss of the Coaches Association, Danny Frawley, even Andrew Bolt is criticising Adam Goodes, but until I see the boys in brown and gold vertical stripes take the field, which due to an elongated round one spread over nine days, is not until next Saturday, I remain unconvinced.

There’s a well-known philosophical thought experiment that poses the question: “If a tree falls in a forest, and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?” This question seeks to test the limits of perception and reality, and I would apply the same test to the AFL: if there’s footy’s on, but no Hawthorn to watch, can it really be said to have started?

Footy, as I see it, starts next week when Hawthorn unfurls the premiership flag at Aurora and then goes out to defend its title.



Hawthorn – soooo last year


You would think, wouldn’t you, that after winning the 2013 premiership, the Hawks would be reasonably well-fancied to win the 2014 premiership? After all, we were hot flag favourites in 2012 and 2013 without having won the previous year’s premierships in 2011 and 2012 respectively. So after a 2013 in which we won 22 of 25 games, overcame our long-time nemesis Geelong, easily defeated the other fancied teams Sydney three times and Fremantle twice, came up against just one team we failed to defeat (Richmond, bizarrely enough), then surely 2014 is shaping as yet another year of high expectations and flag favouritism. But no! It seems that without any intervening matches, unless you count our three practice matches that we’ve won by an average of 100+ points, most commentators are picking Hawthorn to finish somewhere between fourth and sixth, well behind our supposed rivals.

The commentators have picked up where they left off in Grand Final week, and keep banging on about Fremantle – the team who on a bright, sunny day with no breeze managed just 1.6 to half-time in the 2013 Grand Final. I knew we had the flag won at half-time because I thought Fremantle would be too embarrassed to come back out for the second half. But their apparent unwillingness to score doesn’t seem to put off any of the experts. And don’t let their relative goal spree against Collingwood fool you – I could have snuck two or three past the Pies defence on Friday night.

Sydney seems to be the other anointed team, on the basis that they weren’t too bad last year, and now they’ve added Franklin. It’s an okay theory on paper, but it doesn’t take into account the Hawthorn curse – that players who leave are never the same again: Mark Williams, Jonathan Hay, Clinton Young, Campbell Brown just to name a few. It seems that when you take off the brown and gold, you take away some of your ability as well. No surprises there. It also doesn’t take into account that they lost their round one match to GWS.

Writing in the Herald-Sun on 15 March, Dermott Brereton picks Hawthorn to finish outside the top 4 on the basis that our midfield is ageing and we’re likely to suffer all manner of injuries. On the question of injuries, does he know something we don’t? Is it a kind of veiled threat? He writes as if he’s aware of a plague about to sweep through the club.

On the issue of age, I presume that Hawthorn players age at more or less the same rate as players from other clubs, unless they suffer from some sort of HGPS progeria syndrome – or ageing disease. Perhaps he’s just trying to revive the ‘too old, too slow’ tag as a form of reverse psychology to spur on the players. Because it’s not as if Sydney and Freo are in the flush of youth.  Some of their players are so old they were around last time beards were in fashion.

Just on Buddy’s beard, what is going on there? Is he just trying to fit in with his hirsute team mates? Is the cost of living so high in Sydney that no one can afford razors, even on $10 million over nine years? I mean really, at Hawthorn he was a handsome heart throb with dashing good looks, whereas now he looks like someone who’d be stopped for questioning if he tried to get through customs in LAX.

Hawthorn v Melbourne practice match, or why rugby is crap


If, as the experts predict, Hawthorn is not really a premiership threat for 2014, then you wonder how new Demons coach Paul Roos viewed the Hawks’ demolition of Melbourne in the most recent practice match. The final score of 21.16.142 to 4.8.32 suggests the Hawks haven’t lost a lot of their touch.

There’s no real point covering this match – Roughead kicked six and Stratton injured his hamstring, but the only other talking point was Josh Gibson kicking two goals in quick succession. They were good goals too – and wearing the number 6, they had a touch of the Gladys Moncrieff about them.

The only other notable aspect to this match was that nearly 10,000 people turned up to watch – for a practice match!  This in the same week the NRL HQ posited its usual ridiculous prediction that rugby league would overtake the AFL as Australia’s number one footy code, even thought Round one of the NRL drew an average attendance of less than 16,000 people per game. Attendances like that barely warrant putting the game on, let alone declaring imminent domination.

Besides, rugby league won’t overtake the AFL as the number one footy code for one very simple reason – it’s a shit game. It is after all a game in which you move forward by going backwards, so there’s a refutation of logic right there. It’s a game where the only skill is throwing and catching, two aptitudes most people master by about the age of six. It is always amusing to see footage from training of big burly blokes practicing throwing the ball to each other– is it really something you need to practice? Most tellingly, it’s a game where you score by falling over.

Rugby Union is a better game, but it’s still rugby. Its proponents would have us believe that it is a superior sport because it has international reach. But really, any sport in which New Zealand and Wales are the leading powerhouses can hardly be said to be the global game. And if it really is the game they play in heaven, then it simply reinforces preconceptions that heaven is a boring place to be.

The CEO is dead…long live the CEO


AFL CEO Andrew Demetriou has announced that he will resign at the end of the 2014 season. Naturally enough talk has immediately turned to speculation about his successor.

There are some obvious candidates: Gillon McLachlan, Demetriou’s current 2IC, seems to be the early favourite. He is popular in media circles, a jibe that could never be levelled at Demetriou, and with his brother Hamish embedded with host broadcaster Channel 7, pretty much guarantees positive coverage of AFL stories, not unlike state run television in Russia or North Korea. If it is anything like North Korea, however, Hamish would be wise to cultivate a better relationship with Gillon than some of Kim Jung-un’s relatives enjoy with their Supreme Leader. Certainly there will be perceptions of a conflict of interest when the next broadcast rights deal is negotiated, but that is unavoidable anyway; the AFL would be in danger of crumbling into nothing if you were to dismantle every strata of conflict of interest that exists between the AFL, the media and the separate clubs. That’s in no one’s interest.

Of course you can’t use the phrase ‘conflict of interest’ without then citing the name Eddie McGuire, especially if you’re Caroline Wilson. Fairly or unfairly, Eddie is synonymous with conflict of interest, or just Collingwood, and that’s enough to turn everyone off and scupper any ambitions he may harbour of being El Supremo.

Jeff Kennett is another name that is automatically thrown into the ring when any leadership position becomes vacant. Of course it’s usually Jeff tossing the millinery creation, so no one takes much notice. If nothing else he’d make things interesting.

But I feel the AFL needs to look beyond its own to fill this position, and as luck would have it, there are some excellent candidates who have become available in recent months: candidates with worldly experience beyond the small and parochial world of football: candidates who have consorted in the corridors of influence and dabbled in the cut and thrust of global politics. Mary Wooldridge is one such person: having lost Liberal pre-selection for the seat of Doncaster or Kew, or whatever leafy conservative protectorate she resides in, Mary could bring some Spring Street cache to the role. And if Geoff Shaw doesn’t retain the seat of Frankston at the next election, well, perhaps he could bring some of his own Demetriouesque style of debate to proceedings.

Of course, if we’re talking deposed politicians, who is more qualified than ex-lawyer and indeed, ex-PM, Julia Gillard. At least she follows football. Her choice of the Western Bulldogs may seem misguided, and as good a reason as any to have deposed her from The Lodge in the first place, but she could use her position to grant the Scraggers some special treatment. Just on that, if the Sydney Swans and GWS have a higher salary cap commensurate with the higher cost of living in Sydney, based as it is on spiralling real estate prices and the cost of soy-lattes, doesn’t it follow that teams like the Western Bulldogs and Port Adelaide should have a reduced salary cap to match the plummeting real estate of Footscray and Alberton?

Being a modern, thrusting organisation with global reach, the AFL might do well to cast its focus internationally. Exiled Ukrainian President Victor Yanukovych doesn’t have much to do at the moment and like Demetriou, he has the ability to create division and stir discontent. I question his ability to maintain authority if Crimea gets a team in the AFL, but otherwise he could be the man for the job. On the other hand, you have to wonder about life in Ukraine if given the choice, a large proportion of its people would rather be ruled by Russia.

‘Travoltify’ the Brownlow 


Another man who should be considered for the role is John Travolta. I think we all agree that one of the most important roles the CEO undertakes is to read the votes on Brownlow night. No job interview for the new CEO should conclude until the candidate has intoned the words, “Gold Coast. G.Ablett. Three votes” or “Collingwood. S Prestagiacomo one vote” (well, as if he’d ever warrant more than that). This is where Travolta will have a natural advantage, given his recently demonstrated facility for names.

During the Academy Awards John Travolta was introducing the singer who was set to perform the nominated song from the movie, Frozen.  His preamble was going well, but then he introduced Idina Menzel as Adele Dazeem. The best part is he incorporated the caveat ‘the one and only’ into his preamble, when in fact she is neither. It’s not often that a complete nobody performs at the Oscars, but on this occasion it happened, quite literally, because Adele Dazeem didn’t exist until John Travolta invented her.

So if he can’t get the name Idina Menzel correct, what would he do with the names of Hawthorn’s  Brownlow fancies?

Well lucky there’s an app to help us out. Slate.com has an app where you can ‘Travoltify’ your name. You type your name into the field, and the system works out how John Travolta would say it should he ever have occasion to be introducing you at the Academy Awards.

For example, Alastair Clarkson becomes Abigail Crawzford; Luke Hodge is Lee Hufes and Cyril Rioli would be known as Cathal Ramso.

Jarry Roughead transforms into the very exotic sounding Jorja Reezeed, while Sam Mitchell becomes Struan Mitcheem and Matt Spangher is Milo Sgardener.

This could certainly enliven Brownlow night, especially as Gary Ablett winning is a foregone conclusion. Of course if John Travolta became CEO, we'd have to rename the Brownlow as the Hubbard medal. For the record, Andrew Demetriou takes on the somewhat more dashing nomenclature, Ayden Daveries.

"Two votes. Hawthorn, J Reezeed." 


Wednesday 12 March 2014

High on Hawthorn Book Launch - Readings Hawthorn

High on Hawthorn - the book version of Twenty3 - was launched on Wednesday 5 March at Readings bookshop in Hawthorn.

Television identity and radio broadcaster Trevor Marmalade officially launched the book, breaking a bottle of metaphorical champagne over its bow.

In attendance were my friends and family as well as Hawthorn supporters who contributed to the photo section of the book

Below are some of the photos of the night. The gallery will gradually grow commensurate with additions from friends and my patience inserting them.



That's what I call decor






Trevor Marmalade launches High on Hawthorn





The author takes the stand





I think we're discussing exactly how the Hawks will go back to back in 2014



Adding a dedication



Romayne Perera - in the book she has a balloon








Either the camera is at a weird angle, or I am



Great to meet more Hawks!


My 'Garp' moment