Saturday 30 August 2014

Round 22 – Hawthorn v Geelong

MCG, Saturday 23 August 2014

Hawthorn – Bringing Sexy Back


A staple of television entertainment these days is the makeover show, where people are transformed from one state of being into another, altogether higher state of being. Whether it is turning an obese and slovenly person into a slender one, the hideous into the handsome, the fausty into the fashionable or a slattern into a sex siren, these shows take viewers on a journey through the transformation. The concept also applies to professions, turning a cook into a chef or a worker bee into to a boss. It even works for property, turning backyard mires into manicured gardens and hovels into homes. The template for such shows is to begin with a back-story of misfortune and misery and follow the candidates as they undergo a magical metamorphosis from the tragic to the triumphant.

On Saturday night channel 7 screened another in this series of transformations; this time using football as its plot point and Hawthorn as the star. In the first half the Hawks played like inept duffers barely able to gain possession of the ball, and when they did, unable to do anything particularly proactive with it, such as score. When they came out after Clarko’s half-time makeover, however, they were transformed into a ruthless and relentless team that won possession of the ball and moved it with precision, pace and poise. To adopt the theme of the latest makeover show tohit our screens, Hawthorn was bringing sexy back.   

The reason I’m using a television metaphor to describe this game is because that is how I experienced it. I was quite ill in the days leading into this match and was not well enough to attend. In typical Hawthorn mode, I was a late withdrawal. My symptons included an extremely tight chest, harsh dry coughing, fever, nausea, headaches and vomiting. True, nothing entirely unusual leading up to a Geelong match, but serious enough this time that I felt it would be unwise to sit out in the night air growing anxious over the outcome.

This was the first Hawthorn v Geelong home and away game I’d missed since we played at Skilled Stadium in 2007, which was also the last time we beat them in such a fixture. In the interval I’d attended all 12 home and away losses, so note to self, it’s just best if I don’t go.

Taking Turns

While most commentary about the match is running with the ‘game of two halves’ angle, it was more a case of the two teams taking turns to enjoy sustained bursts of goal scoring. Geelong kicked the first three of the game, then Hawthorn kicked the next three, then Geelong kicked six, then Hawthorn kicked a decisive 10 in a row, before Geelong added two. Brad Sewell started the next Hawthorn burst but the final siren rang before we could add any further goals.

Along the way there were a number of highlights. Rough’s two goals just before quarter time to get us going in the game, the dual between Brian Lake and Tom Hawkins, no clear winner, but both played well, Jimmy Bartel’s elaborate dive which earnt him a pefect 10 and a free kick in front of goal – a triple pike with a touch of Lindsay Thomas – it was the final link in a chain of doubtful free kicks to Geelong that awoke the Hawthorn crowd who responded with impressive and sustained booing every time Bartel went near the ball for the rest of the night. It was heartening to hear. Bartel can protest his innocence all he likes, but sorry Jimmy, the people saw and the people have spoken.

Geelong fans, players and the Geelong-centric media contingent who cast Lindsay Thomas as a serial cheat two weeks previous when he took a dive against the Cats to win a free kick in front of goal suddenly found themselves having to see things from a different perspective and fell over themselves to clear Bartel’s name.

If this incident angered the Hawthorn fans, it merely served as a focal point for our frustration after Geelong added five goals in succession to lead by 31 points at half-time. We’d only scored 3.2 to that point – five scoring shots in a half of football was the real problem.

Transformation Time

There were some encouraging signs early in the third quarter, with Hawthorn maintaining possession and setting up a string of scoring opportunites. The problem was that all of our scores were behinds – the Poo kicked two, Breust and Spangher one each.  Then the ball went down the other end and Hawkins goaled for Geelong – our best period of the game and we were just getting further behind. The deficit was 33 points.

How to explain what happened next? At home, where I’d been lying on the couch making the most of my illness, my son Oscar returned from his night out. The ‘Go Cats’ taunts of his friends ringing in the air as they drove away. Was it his coming home that turned things around?

Was it something more spiritual or cosmic? The deficit, after all, was 33 points – the age at which Christ was killed, but more importnatly, came back to life.

Just like the Hawks with Jordan Lewis being instrumental in this miracle. He set up David Hale for a goal, then marked and kicked one himself. Will Langford was also a key player – winning a free kick and scoring. The free kick wasn’t there, but it was now our turn to enjoy a little umpiring providence. Luke Breust, barely sighted before now, marked a Birchall pass and kicked accurately.

The umpiring providence was short-lived however, as Sam Mitchell’s GOAL was reviewed and despite the ball clearing the line before Hamish McIntosh got his mit to it, it was awrded as a point. It seems that every week the goal review system creates the very controversy it was introduced to eliminate. It is either not used when it shoud be, used when it shouldn’t be, or delivers an incorrect result. Let’s just go back to the goal umpires – there’s far less guesswork.

It didn’t really matter beause about a minute later David Hale ran back with the flight of the ball and launched into a mark directly in front. The transformation was complete when Langford took a mark and kicked a long goal from 50 metres tp put us in front as the siren sounded.

The Hawks had the momentum and the crowd was roaring – surely we couldn’t lose it from here. Well no Hawthorn fans that have been to these matches over the past few years were thinking such thoughts – we’ve learnt that when it comes to Geelong games, optimism can be the first sign of weakness. Still, things were markedly better than they were at half-time.

Liam Shiles kept the momentum and our (dis)belief bubbling along when he goaled from a pack less than a minute after the restart. And in a sign that this really was going to be our night, even Jonathan Ceglar drifted forward to take a mark and goal. Birchall passed to Roughead for anoher and then Hale kicked his third. Suddenly we were 5 goals up!

The Cats kicked a couple to keep our anxiety alive, but Brad Sewell, playing his first game for several weeks, wheeled around from a pack and slotted the sealer with five minutes remaining.

In a makeover show, this would be the bit when the relatives tear up, hug each other and become emotional and that’s exactly what was happening at my place.

Lewis, Birchall, Langford, Gibson, Lake, Burgoyne and Mitchell all brought a little bit of sexy back for the Hawks on the night.


Final scores: Hawthorn 14 10 94 d Geelong 11 5 71

Attendance: 72,212

Ladder position: 2nd


What we learned: The Catholic Church is like a trucking company. Giving evidence this week at the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sex Abuse, Cardinal George Pell likened the Catholic Church’s responsibility over child abuse at the hands of priests to that of a trucking company when one of their drivers sexually assaults a passenger.  This analogy is wrong on so many levels we don’t know where to start, but victims of sexual abuse as well as people who run trucking companies are understandably upset by the comparison. It is unclear how many truck drivers are entrusted with the spiritual and moral guidance of children they happen to pick up along the highway, let alone how many might abuse that trust, but the fact that the Royal Commission wasn’t set up to look into the activities of trucking companies suggests that it is not as common as Cardinal Pell may think. If Cardinal Pell wants the Catholic Church to be more like a trucking company, perhaps they could start by paying taxes.

What has this got to do with football? Well, nothing actually. 


What we already knew: Carlton is not getting better any time soon. After losing by 103 points to Port Adelaide on Friday night, their VFL affiliate side, the Northern Blues lost to the Box Hill Hawks by 129 points, and the development league side, their third tier team, also lost to Box Hill by 119 points. So Carlton’s three teams lost by an aggregate of 351 points on the weekend - who would want to ask Mick Malthouse the first question at that press conference?


What we loved: The mighty Mosquitos! In the precursor to the Hawthorn Geelong game on Saturday night, Papua New Guinea defeated Ireland by 3 points in the final of AFL International Cup: 6.9.45 to 6.6.42. PNG’s Mosquitos came from behind at three quarter time to win their second title. Meanwhile Canada won the women’s title, also defeating Ireland: 5.8.38 to 2.0.12. This growth of serious AFL teams is encouraging as we may need a replacement for Melbourne in the near future.



What we are saddened by: Terrible news during the week that former Essendon player and Melbourne coach, Neale Daniher, has motor neuron disease – a disease that is both fatal and incurable. This news comes as the ice-bucket challenge sweeps the world. To raise awareness for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) or motor neuron disease in Australia, people with smart phones or access to a TV crew are subjecting themselves to having a bucket of iced water tipped over their heads. Now that everyone with any sort of vague media profile, except perhaps the Pope, the Queen and John Kennedy Snr have taken the challenge, we can consider awareness well and truly raised. Critics may see the campaign as little more than a celebrity wet t-shirt competition, but hopefully the campaign will continue to raise funds towards research for a cure to help good people like Neale Daniher.

No comments:

Post a Comment